Tuesday, October 22, 2019

Post-Modern African Catholicity, the Two Thirds Perspective


Sometimes we tend to live as if we don't have any theology or simply not interested in theology altogether. The people of God seem to be disillusioned and a bit mesmerized by what is happening in the Catholic Church as a whole and disgusted by their local ordinaries and people of the cloth at the local level. This if not so is a glim picture in most African countries. The situation seems to be out of hand from pedophiles crime, corruption, scandals, syncretism, murders, mismanagement, poor leadership and lack of direction. These are challenges we in the two-thirds of the world are being confronted with. Maybe let's call it third world countries, maybe that is a more easy term our mind is accustomed to.
The pastors seem to be contented to remain in the parishes waiting for the sheep rather than going out to look for the one lost ones, the 99 sheep look worth enough that why bother to go out to look for that other one which on its own volition decided to leave the group to look for another route. How many times do we too find ourselves in this state in our day to the Christian life? This is the kind of picture many people of God have of the Church, a church self-sufficient, autonomous and self-actualized, no need to go out because it's already out there, the brand is clear, no big deal.
For many years we can remember, we have all depended on the priests, and bishops for all sorts of solution, because of we have grown thinking that they are the ones whom God listens more than us, that in itself shows that we have lived in that sin without confessing for a long time sin of overdependence or call it parasitic attitude: economically, spiritually, family, counsel management. It is now dawning on us that we need to reclaim our rightful place and our called upon obligations as Christians baptized and sent out. The bishops and priests have to allow professionalism to take place and proper leadership and management skills applied in church management.
The church is not for the world and needs to be out of the world. The church is in the world and has to not only use modern tools of the world but the same tools but a different form of approach, this world which is globalized, fluid and politically perfumed. The church seems to be lost in the busy commercial business centers and completely her voice choked with the world demands and pressures. Today it's easy to get a stressed priest than a happy and contented priest, why? The priests are also struggling to make ends meet, the priest has business entrepreneurs, their own investments, dress in ties instead of white collars, they are dressed in style, drive posh cars and also swing themselves with modern smartphones and life is cool…The churches are abandoned, how can you know when a priest has abandoned his church post, look at the confession boxes, full of dust, dark, mosquito breeding places, altar clothes dirty, chalices which have never seen Brasso cream, etc., but he drivers a new car for that matter.
This kind of status quo needs a complete overhaul, rebranding, renewal, remembering African values and religious heritage. This has to find itself in the core of African theology and philosophy, where harmony has to be rediscovered within its diversity. The African church has been seduced into socio-economic and political imperatives of development and her challenges overwhelmingly mishandled by her pastors, the priests, and bishops. Politicians are calling shots with a lot of big sums of money, where bishops are rewarded with cars by the government of the day and we all know that politicians don't give everything for free, selling the pulpit/ambo to the crooked politicians. Every year episcopal conferences issue pastoral letters to the nation but these letters seem written for others not for themselves to follow but their sheep.
The local ordinaries should believe in what they write to their Christians, they can’t be in our eyes as special people who do nothing except command and wait for offertory in their residences. The bishops have to fold their sleeves and get into the vineyard to work, weed, and harvest and carry the yields to the church. Paul says a bishop who doesn’t pastor his sheep should not eat. For many years most dioceses and Catholic Church has been managed by missionaries from abroad, but with time, now we have African local sons of the soil. But these African bishops should be Africans.
John Paul II on his first trip to Africa he said: In Africa, there is certainly maturity, a youthful maturity, a joyful maturity, a strong maturity, and the maturity of being themselves, of finding themselves in the church as in their church, not in the church imported from elsewhere. This is their church, the church lived in an authentic, African way.
This is itself shows that African bishops need space, freedom and creatively already in 1969, Paul VI speaking in Kampala had proclaimed Africa’s right to create her Christianity. In the expression of a single faith, pluralism is legitimate, even desirable, in this sense you may and you must have an African Christianity.
This we see it being built up or emphasized by John Paul II in 1980 when he said Not only is Christianity important to Africa, but Christ himself, in his body is African. Sometimes we tend to enter into a western ideological attitude of thinking that the mission, the African church has to be built by the missionaries. The people should be helped to be self-reliance to face the economic-financial challenges, enough is going on around that needs to be tapped. Missionaries can only be guests who come from abroad and who are welcomed among them, can at the best be of some assistance, at worst, you can be an obstacle unless they help the people the missionaries work to no end but demission.
African theology has to train pastoral agents who are all surrounded and self-reliant without having the temptation of falling into the comfort of the sacristy and only waiting for benefactors for doing many projects with little to do with spiritual renewal of their people they serve. Most of the dioceses fall into the temptations of ready-made consumers good parachuted from abroad. Our formation institutions have to rediscover traditional values and reclaim the reflection of being truly Christian, truly Africans to continue growing in cultural heritage. The seminarians are to be helped to cultivate culture and hard work to build the African church, for they are the force of the church for tomorrow. There should be an awareness of what evangelization is all about. In the past the seminarians would be sent to ask the people and then bring back the report, they had the opportunity to talk to the people and question them on various items and issues because the people of God were the protagonist, today it remains the work of library and in the comforts of theological rooms and debates about what may bedeviling the people of God, theology is done for the people of God rather than doing theology together with the people of God.
Today the people of God should be helped not to depend on priests nor missionaries but they should reorganize their christian community in such a way that portrays a true church that is alive and well. The right place to start this renewal is in the area of liturgy as it brings together the greatest number of ways of expressing faith. In this, we need to rediscover the power of bodily expression, especially in terms of gestures and rhythms, and rhythmic movement that can even become a dance. Artistic creations bring outlines, shapes, symbols, and colors that have special meaning for a particular community beats of drums, tonalities, that are in time with the soul. The composers of these chants are not always priests or religious but often laypeople.
The homilies during mass should bring back the climate of dialogue as a means of community participation in the thought of the preacher. These thoughts are tested and verified by the community. The assembly expresses their reactions spontaneously and truly in dialogue. The preacher receives direct feedback on his thoughts through these reactions, and he will know whether he has been understood, and whether there agreement or not. In the end the community sings the credo, this truly reflects a consensus and expression of shared faith, and together they stand in the light of the word of God. Direct contact with a word of God is what they ask for, right there where the spirit breathes. This requires effort of interpretation. Pope Paul VI got it right away when he landed on the African soil:
"You remain sincerely African even in your interpretation of Christian life, you will be able to formulate Catholicism in terms that are absolutely appropriate to your culture, and you will be able to bring to the catholic church the precious and original contributions as sons and daughters of Africa, which is particularly in need at this hour of its history”. Africans have to start a creative theology that seeks new ways to express their faith in the liturgy. In any celebration, there are moments of welcome and exchange of greetings. In the church, we need to think very well, where we can offer a sign of peace in the Church, especially when we live in a church where reconciliation is at the centre of the people's lives. To many, it would be right and fitting after the penitential rite, and not after the Lord’s Prayer. This doesn’t mean we want to change the liturgy, but try it out because we have catholic groups who do it like the new catechumenates. As Pope Francis says, let’s not through the Holy Spirit out of the hall during the Pan Amazonian Synod. Sometimes we have to confront certain realities and contexts that we confront every day of our lives on the road to holiness. We become reconciled and we enter into the communal celebration with hearts pure and fresh.
But from the trend of things in the Catholic Church, some of these changes need to be discussed by the heads of the church, and yet the people who live the reality do not see the need for it once it is brought back with a European tool kit. This is what the Pan Amazonian synod is struggling within these days of October at the Vatican to respond to the needs of the regions. With the scarcity of priests, that means there are few celebrations of the Eucharist…the laypeople have to invent a way of evangelization in this scarcity. From the look of things, nobody is so taken up by the issue of whether theologically and politically.
In the African context, the family is the true structure of understanding the African church, without this in mind we may be doing evangelization in futility. It's not enough to just theorize about development, but it's also essential that we have a good foundation of what we are theorizing. The emergence of small Christian communities is reliable bases from which to promote a holistic approach to development that will last. These small communities should provide:
a)      A setting which the organic functions of traditional solidarity can expand a sense of responsibility can be awakened, especially among the laity; a spirit of relationship and sharing. This is a typically African culture that has to be fostered and deepened.
b)      We need to build up an African spirit of evangelization, a new inspiration for a new culture, not only for Christians but for non-Christians as well.
c)      We as Africans have to be mature to have our self-criticism. It's easy to criticize others, but self-criticism is another ball game altogether. In any Christian community, it's inescapable as it is that of the family. We are being faced with modern trends where we are picking up on traditional values and rediscovering self-criticism in a group setting. We need to be responsible and committed to our call to make sure that African catholicity is fully alive as a church. This calls for a change of attitude in our thinking and to reflect instead of expecting the priests to provide ready-made answers. Today the people of God have to know that they are responsible for their church even to the point of expressing appropriate opinions, and this gives them a desire for information and formation (cf. the millennial generation epoch).
d)     Our ancestors like John S. Mbiti and the rest who have gone before us in faith to the creator, whose writings and courage, remolded and rehabilitated the bleeding African dignity, cultural and religious heritage that slavery and western colonialism we are a celebration is what we have to own in the name of ATR and to study it like any other religion on the globe, not a religion of spirits, mixed with witchcraft which even they tell us is something good, the western world are good at bullying Africans more so when they don’t understand what an African mind is up to. We now need to speak out, shout out and they have to listen. Mbiti and his colleagues taught us to see our African religions and cultural heritage as valid ingredients for theologizing and authentic inculturation of the gospel in Africa, form the context of African, and its perspectives.
Ancestors are mediators of life, of blessings and of virtues, all of which have their sources in God. They are also models for taking responsibility for life. This acceptance of responsibility concerning life brings us back to life and at the same time transmitting the same life to others. This is our moral obligation as Africans to state our case and presentation without fear of anything or anyone or power. African ancestors are models of saints of the family, saints of the clan. This has to be fully understood or reduced to a biological level alone. It's just enough to make Jesus vibrant, entirely cared for, and secure. Yes, Jesus is our Ancestor. He is no stranger since he admitted and understood as an ancestor. He belongs to us and we to him, he is our own. We have to think of Jesus as a person-oriented towards a living person, on a spiritual level. Because what is involved here is a personal relationship with the living Christ-ancestor, older brother, a liberator. This is understood at the levels of celebrations, ceremonies and rituals, religions, because in an African family the stages are punctuated by dowries and births, depending on the region and population concerned. It is as widely practiced as had been an original thought.
Polygamy form is the result of social tolerance. It attempts to resolve certain problems raised by the experience of the first complete marital contract which is, in fact, monogamous. A dowry is usually paid in the initial phase, not by the betrothed alone, but by his family with or without his contribution. There has been an evolution in it but the structure has not changed. There has incorrect to continue imaging that polygamy is the original and most common means of marriage in Africa. That form is monogamy, beyond all possible doubt. One can state today as a definite fact that sociological proof has conquered the cultural truth about these forms of marriage. A theological reflection can now lead us with some certainty to valid pastoral guidelines.
Today we do not want anybody to translate African realities in their own eyes but have to allow Africans to tell their stories as they are also open to the international global perspective. As they say until the lions learn how to write its story, the hunter will always write the victory story. Sometimes Africans write stories, experiences but they have simply brushed aside, or no publishing house is interested to publish them, hostility is emitted right from the presentation by the people we call book reviewers because they do not just understand what it is all about and it looks they will never understand.
We need to spread the word, shed light on the cultural, spiritual, moral, social and scientific complexity of our African traditions. Why? All expressions of evil the counterpoint of life, have been lumped together and label it witchcraft. This is a pejorative label and one that is inappropriate. This has led to the marginalization of the essential values which have been consistently ignored, misunderstood, and despised. This is a great challenge to theology. This challenge has to lead us towards a new consciousness and new demands for a theology of Christ, whereby it has also to give us the impetus to boldly set ourselves to work. The African educative systems must initiate and inculcate moral and traditional values, which should not only be academic but those values written in the hearts, stories narrated as a way of cultural formation.
There should be room created for something new and truly lived. The big question is. Is the west in the state of listening and accepting similar cultural kenosis in collaborating with African Traditional religion and philosophy? The pastoral aspects signify the necessity for faith to express itself within an adequate discernment to that of apostles in Jerusalem and Vatican II, reading the signs of the time. The light of the Holy Spirit leads us to discover the problem, the strength of the Spirit will lead us to find the solution.


© Nyamunga Joeseph Nyamunga'19


Saturday, October 12, 2019

THE AMAZON SYNOD, "Do Not Throw the Holy Spirit Out of the Hall..."


The Amazon Synod, the Role Women in the Evangelization: As Seen and Lived by An African Missionary, Context of Bolivia

By. Nyamunga J.B (MA PastoralTheol CUEA/ Lic. Missiologia, PUU Roma)



The Latin American woman and above all a Bolivian woman in that matter is today rejecting the place assigned to her by men, of being passive, inferior, emotional, irrational, and sinner par excellence, she has discovered the new face of her identity, becoming increasingly visible and speaking up in society and the church. She feels this is the right moment for her new historical moment, a time fecund with proper new fighting frontiers out of poverty. Like Mary Magdalene, the Bolivian woman is rightly reading into the Bible to bear witness to the resurrection and deny the final triumph of death over life. They are becoming witnesses to life in despair and defeat, proclaiming the opening up new roads of hope, looking at a great Bolivian fighter, defender, and liberator called Bartolina Sisa as the model of their struggles.(Cf. the confederation of Women Bartolina Sisa Foundation -Bolivia) 

Bartolina Sisa was an indigenous woman who mobilized her people more so the indigenous women to wage war against the yoke which the Spaniards had placed on them, together with her husband Tupac Katari, today most rural indigenous women confederation in Bolivia take up her name as a true model of emancipation and liberation, to them, she was a martyr, brutally killed. She was born on 25 August 1750, in the province called Loayza department of La Paz (Political capital of Bolivia, while the constitutional capital is in the department called Sucre).
The spirit was towards forming small groups where women and men toiled side by side and witnessed even up to their martyrdom. This was all towards the women desire for freedom, combating the colonizers in Latin America. This was taking place in the whole of las Americas…seeking change, which later came to be hijacked by the military regimes from the 1960s in many Latin American countries. 

In Brazil for example in 1964 the military government closed down all institutions of civil society or put an army general in charge of them. The only institution that was not under the military was the church, which became a privileged space where people could still meet to discuss their problems. It was during this time that the faith came to be understood as having social implications. This is the time we can say was the strongest in the Brazilian church. This meant that students and priests became involved in social problems, and some went to live in urban slums or poor rural communities. Living closer to the poor, they came to understand that religious salvation was to be obtained through their commitment to the here and now of the suffering "other". (Cf. Sobrino 1984:96-103).

The bible study groups began to appear, reflecting on the word of God and comparing it with their own lives. The members gradually discovered ways to aid themselves on their journey along the road of faith towards the building of God’s Reign. These Bible study groups were also the germinating seeds of the basic ecclesiastical commitment (CEBs) a new way of being for the church on our continent. It was precisely the CEBs that women began to exercise a new and important role by assuming leadership positions, stimulating and promoting many services such as works of charity, teaching catechism, organizing liturgy, spreading the word of God. The predominantly male face of the church began to change. This will remind you that generally that Latin America women are more religious men. They experience God in their day-to-today lives and their hope for a better future they march on and are still marching on.

Thus the church in Latin America a continent which is so rich and yet so exploited and so full of misery has always made the preferential choice towards the poor. It is usually the women who suffer most from violence and exploitation. Hence the clamour of women emerges from within the cry of the oppressed, imploring the heavens for a place, for space. The difficult task of building the Reign of God involves the concrete struggles of women, all kinds of persons marginalized from society. These grass-roots movements began in the community centres of the churches. The organizational form that became the most important was the Mother's clubs who always hold their weekly meetings of women in the church hall to learn how to sew and to join scraps of cloths together to male clothes and quilts, where they also reflect on the word of God. They work together and begin to trust in each other and see their lives form common perspective, just like any other normal women chamas- Swahili for women clubs, merry go around, or micro-finance organization, a strong bond of solidarity arises among them.

From the communitarian experiences, women discover the strengths of being united and organized and begin participating in people's movements. They begin to struggle for a better life for all, in this manner following Jesus Christ who came to bring "life and life plentiful" (John 10:10). They are always prepared to open themselves up to more to the world, they feel the crushing weight of male chauvinism. Going to church and community meetings is one thing, but getting involved in social movements is another. After all the home is a proper place for women, the men claim. Thus the women have to struggle not only against their husbands at home but also against other men at the union hall, in associations, and at political meetings. These struggles are usually undertaken together with others for better living conditions. The first demands are always about better health conditions, then schools, for better transportation, and for a place where they can plant and live in short, for the basic elements necessary to be able to live a proper human existence.

Their struggles have always led to victories. Many have been taken prisoner, tortured, killed. But female resistance is a hidden force which they have. Their lives, which have been marked by oppression and marginalization, have given them fibre, and the will to struggle, anchored in faith and hope. The strength emerges especially at moments of crisis, such as widowhood (Ruth, Gen.38) or war (Judith). So they continue courageously the struggle to build a better world for their children and grandchildren. 

Movements of women from among the working classes of Brazil continue or emerge today. They are sustained by faith and by the churches and make their presence felt particularly concerning social questions. The situation arising from the shortage of priests, these women become involved with the people in a way that contributes enormously to their unity and organization. They call reflective groups together, they pray and moved by their faith in God and their confidence in life and love. They have not given up amidst the difficulties that unveil in their struggles. They are fully engaged in coordination, inspiration, catechism, liturgy, Bible study groups, helping the needy, and so forth.

The participation of women in society leads them to express their very lives in the struggle for better living conditions for all. In the communities, the women draw from the Bible and find that they too have citizenship in the church due to the rights conferred upon them by the sacrament of baptism. This was clearly stated during the participation of women at the Sixth Inter-ecclesial Meeting of the Basic Ecclesial Communities) (Cf. REV (Brazilian Ecclesiastical Review). Through these experiences, they discover that their space in the church as beloved daughters of God. In the CEBs they are no longer just a passive presence, but discover new ecclesiological values and bring up new questions for theology.

Most of these CEBs are outskirts where even the means of transport is a hell of an experience that if you have no fibre for a mission you give up before reaching, this is the reality we are dealing with in the Amazon Synod. Majority of women who live in these poor areas, most of them are responsible for parishes, assuming the functions previously reserved to the clergy. These new practices besides questioning the mode of their consecration bring them closer to the people. Such living experience involves them closer to the challenges: marriage, abortion, sexual relationships, violence against women, motherhood, educating and raising children, the drama of the unwed mother, and so forth. All these lead to religious women to a discovery of herself as a woman. 

They are now rereading the Bible as a history of a people linked to the poor by religious tradition and from whom they can learn faith in day-to-day life. There is a discovery of the image of God committed to the liberation of the oppressed, of a more approachable Jesus who chose his friends and followers from among those on the fringes of society, and new image of Mary, closer to the problem of women, not as a passive and subordinate woman but as active and participating and having prophetic dimension. (Cf. Mary Mother of Jesus, 1981).

The women catechists are the ones who are responsible for most systematic initiation into the Christian faith, mainly of children and adolescents. Eighty per cent of these are dedicated to catechism are women. The evangelical strength of the catechists is tremendous, not in the sense of memorizing, but in developing an impressive dimension of creativity. This is Latin America is a revolutionary task that the church cannot afford to ignore. They are open to an effective and shared manner to the problem of their people. They are capable not just militant activity in the people's struggle for justice, by the valuing of life, by the importance of sharing goods in short, by an alternative to our consumerist society.

As a result of these diverse pastoral activities, a woman whether as a religious amid the people, or as a catechism teacher, or as a layperson engages in the movement or religious activity begins to feel the need to reflect on her faith. Reality raises so many questions for the Christian faith. And in the trying to respond to these challenges, the woman begins to study theology to have improved pastoral participation, taking the example of Martha of Bethany as an inspiring figure for women. According to the gospels she managed to combine domestic chores (Luke 10:38, John 12:2) with religious commitment and also theological reflection. Luke and John present her as a deaconess, a technical term used to designate service to the community. Jesus makes his supreme revelation to Martha. "I am the resurrection and life". He explains precisely what kind of messiah he is. And he asks, "Do you believe this?” Martha responds with a magnificent declaration of faith: Yes Lord you are the Christ, the son of God who is to come. Until now theology has been the exclusive sphere of men. Today women are perceiving their way of creating theology where the elements of daily life are intimately mixed with talk of God. 

A woman who knows intimately the fragility of life, the need to shelter and protect it, has also an original point of view regarding the creator of life, that the same God who through the Bible, speaks to us of the fullness of life, that same God who, through the Bible, speaks to us of the fullness of human beings. This is because of a woman's way of being, thinking, and living has never learned how to be compartmentalized. This tells you more than women who do theology in academic centres tend to be always in contact with their fellow sisters from poor classes. A woman's theological thought and deeds are always in solidarity with the situation of others and are the fruit of her compassion and identification with them. As she theologizes the life experienced by all God's daughters and sons are always towards the integral dignity. (Cf. Maria Clara Binger, 1986:19).

The Amazon synod as Pope Francis says "let us not kick the Holy Spirit out of the Hall" for Pope John XXIII set the stage by his revolutionary statement "let's open the windows to feel the breath of the Holy Spirit". One may ask himself or herself what these two have in common. They are completely centred on the Holy Spirit and they want the Holy Spirit to cause some bit of movement, now that the Holy Spirit is here with us whether you closed the window, or throw Him out, something will have turned around the whole ambient, that those who want to throw it out, might be the ones catapulted to speak with the power of the same to change the reality before their eyes.

The world of today is not only witnessing the phenomenon of women voices coming out of oppression but a shaped and focused vision, not what their brothers, husbands or the Church want for them but what they, themselves are making, the voices of faith to be heard by the modern world. They are saying Here we are here also to be counted. They have decided to take their destiny into their hands and for this, they will have to fight through the dominant masculine world with their given God gifted ways and nurture. They are moving away from oppression, the complainer, the forgotten, the little-remembered, women today are starting to be heard, they are making their presence felt, taking on more and more jobs and functions, carrying out tasks of responsibility and explaining in a new discourse their new ways of being and doing.


Bibliography References

Sobrino J., The The manifestation of the God of Life in Jesus of Nazareth,(Sao Paulo: Paulinas 1984),96-103.

CAVALACANTI, T., “On the Participation of Women at the Sixth Inter-ecclesiastical Meeting of the Basic Ecclesial Communities”, in REV (Brazilian Ecclesiastical Review).

Gebara, Y., “Women Make Theology”, in REB 46 (Petropolis: Vozes, 1986).

Binger, C.M., “And Woman Broke Her Silence”, in Perspectiva Teologica 46 (September/December 1986.

GIVING LIFE TO THE NEW UNDERSTANDING OF EVANGELIZATION ( Evangelii Gaudium)

      II LEZIONE   1. Finalità di EG: dare vita ad una nuova tappa evangelizzatrice 1.1. Avendo presente la tematica sviluppata ...